Head Above Water

Upon encountering a cabbage floating in the River Thames, the main character in Russell Hoban’s The Medusa Frequency hallucinates: the cabbage becomes the severed head of Orpheus, drifting in the current, murmuring stories. An image that borders on the absurd, almost comical.

According to myth, after the Maenads, raving female followers of Dionysos, tear Orpheus apart in a ritual frenzy, his head and lyre float down the River Hebros, still singing, still playing. Apollonian order and harmony are undone by ecstatic chaos.

The dismembered, floating head of Orpheus became a favored subject among Symbolist and Pre-Raphaelite painters of the 19th century, always suspended between pathos and detachment. There is survival in this image, but it is survival as estrangement: the head without the body, still sounding, but adrift, without the will to seek an audience. It is displaced in an unsettling way.

It reminds me of Goya’s El Perro (The Dog), from the Black Paintings, showing only the dog’s head, nostrils just above an undefined mass into which he seems to be sinking. Like Orpheus’s head, it is cut off from its body, its environment unclear, suspended in the empty verticality of the painting.

In Greek mythology, Poseidon, the god of water, also created the horse. Perhaps there is an association to be made between a galloping horse, its mane flying, and the movement of water in waves. In a way, the seahorse, with its horse-like head and curled fishtail, reflects another possible connection.

Still, although naturally capable of swimming, a horse appears completely alien in the water. Its body is essentially made for running. The long, tapered legs struggle to keep the nostrils above the surface, to fill the large lungs with air, which, in turn, keep the heavy body afloat.

There is a poem by Boris Slutsky titled Horses in the Ocean, about a sinking ship and the thousand horses it carried as cargo, now forced to swim. Here is a translated excerpt:

As for the horses, their plight was grim,
For, like it or not, they had to swim.

On and on they swam after the boats,
An island of horses with red-brown coats.

At first, they were calm, for they did not dream
That the ocean was anything but a stream.

But it stretched without end like a wintry night,
And the longed-for land was never in sight.

On their watery way all their strength was spent,
And they whinnied in fear and in wonderment.

They whinnied and neighed and struggled for breath,
As down they went to their watery death.

I can imagine the surface of the water as a horizontal cut. Not violent, but a cut formed by its own visual logic. What remains above — the head — is shown. Below is only speculation.

Russell Hoban, The Medusa Frequency.
Russell Hoban, The Medusa Frequency.
The Death of Orpheus, detail from a silver kantharos, 420–410 BC. Vassil Bojkov Collection, Sofia, Bulgaria.
The Death of Orpheus, detail from a silver kantharos, 420–410 BC. Vassil Bojkov Collection, Sofia, Bulgaria.
Henri Léopold Lévy, The Death of Orpheus, 1866.
Henri Léopold Lévy’s The Death of Orpheus (c. 1870), Art Institute of Chicago.
Jean Delville, The Death of Orpheus, 1893. Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, Brussels.
Jean Delville, The Death of Orpheus, 1893. Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, Brussels.
John William Waterhouse, oil sketch for The Head of Orpheus, c. 1900.
John William Waterhouse, oil sketch for The Head of Orpheus, c. 1900.
Odilon Redon, Head of Orpheus Floating in the Water (also known as The Mystic), 1881. Charcoal and black chalk on paper. Kröller-Müller Museum, Otterlo, Netherlands.
Odilon Redon, Head of Orpheus Floating in the Water (also known as The Mystic), 1881. Charcoal and black chalk on paper. Kröller-Müller Museum, Otterlo, Netherlands.
Gustave Moreau, Orphée, 1865. Musée d’Orsay, Paris.
Gustave Moreau, Orphée, 1865. Musée d’Orsay, Paris.
The floating head of Orpheus also appears in Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman comics.
The floating head of Orpheus also appears in Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman comics.
Francisco de Goya, El Perro (The Dog), c. 1819–1823. Museo del Prado, Madrid.
Francisco de Goya, El Perro (The Dog), c. 1819–1823. Museo del Prado, Madrid.
Boris Slutsky, author of Horses in the Ocean.
Boris Slutsky, author of Horses in the Ocean.
Poseidon mosaic, Gaziantep Zeugma Mosaic Museum, Turkey.
Poseidon mosaic, Gaziantep Zeugma Mosaic Museum, Turkey.
Oil sketch by Peter Paul Rubens, depicting Neptune calming a storm at sea. Harvard Art Museums.
Oil sketch by Peter Paul Rubens, depicting Neptune calming a storm at sea. Harvard Art Museums.
Horses swimming.
Horses swimming.
The Torrent and the River, from Fables by Jean de La Fontaine. Engraving after Gustave Doré.
The Torrent and the River, from Fables by Jean de La Fontaine. Engraving after Gustave Doré.
Mockup of a horse head, built as a preparatory model for Philipp Fröhlich's painting.
Mockup of a horse head, built as a preparatory model for the painting.
Assembled mockup by Philipp Fröhlich, used in preparation for the painting.
Assembled mockup used in preparation for the painting.
Oil sketch by Philipp Fröhlich showing a swimming horse
Oil sketch (346H), 2021 24,5 x 17,5 cm
Oil sketch by Philipp Fröhlich showing a swimming horse
Oil sketch (347H), 2021 27,5 x 19,5 cm
The framed painting of a swimming horse by Philipp Fröhlich, hanging on a studio wall.
The framed painting on the studio wall.
A painting of a swimming horse, by Philipp Fröhlich: (350L), 2021, oil on canvas, 175 x 120 cm
(350L), 2021, oil on canvas, 175 x 120 cm

Sign up to receive a brief update every two weeks when a painting is added.