Ring a Ring o’ Roses

Rubens’ Dance of Mythological Figures and Villagers, tucked into a corner of the Prado, may be small by his scale, but it’s one of my favorites. A swirl of bodies, sweat, and joy—this is the group dance as ideal. Sensual and communal, fluid and timeless, it’s all about shared delight.

Years ago, I was invited to a Scottish party in Madrid and was stunned that everyone seemed to know—and willingly partake in—the group dances. There was something incredibly uniting in moving through a fixed, shared choreography.

Then, a couple of weeks ago, I was invited to a Spanish wedding. It was a great party, but I couldn’t help noticing that the only collective dances were the Macarena and “Saturday Night.” As silly as they seem, there’s still an echo of ritual embedded in the kitsch. We gather, move, and mark time together—creating, however briefly, a shared group identity.

Being at the wedding made me think about how deeply the need for shared movement runs through human culture—whether preserved consciously or passed down in half-forgotten rituals.

The winding procession of the Polonaise is especially apt for this. Participants snake around the room in an informal line, each placing their hands on the shoulders or waist of the person ahead. It might make us cringe, but its structure preserves remnants of processional ritual. And in its simplicity, it remains a masterpiece of inclusion.

But the most basic—and at the same time the most meaningful—of all group dances is the circle dance. They range from children’s Ring a Ring o’ Roses to the famous circle dances of Native Americans and the Jewish Hora, to the ancient Choreia of Greece. There are even cave paintings showing human figures dancing in rings. Dancing in a circle is so inherently archaic that I doubt there is a culture that hasn’t adopted it in some form.

At the Carnival of Binche, the Gilles dance in slow, weighted circles, their movements heavy with ritual meaning but without a marked center. On Walpurgisnacht, witches dance around fires, and the center becomes a site of transformation and invocation. In Stravinsky’s Rite of Spring, the circle tightens to its extreme: a frenetic whirl that culminates in the selection and sacrifice of a single dancer.

The circle might be an empty space—an invocation of unity—or it can be a place of containment and transformation. To be at the center is to be marked. It is a site of honor, danger, or metamorphosis. In circle dances, the center can hold the fire, the chosen pair, the scapegoat, or the sacrificial victim. To be placed at the center is to be seen and set apart, to be celebrated or consumed.

In the fairy tale The Wolf and the Seven Little Kids from the Brothers Grimm, it is the well that becomes the center. The wolf is tricked and drowned, his belly filled with stones, and cast down the vertical, dark axis in the middle. The goat kids, rebirthed out of the belly of the wolf, celebrate not just survival but the triumph of innocence over danger. It is the restoration of order—the brief, ecstatic moment when fear is overcome and turned into ritual motion.

Peter Paul Rubens, Dance of Mythological Figures and Villagers Oil on canvas, ca. 1635–38. Museo del Prado, Madrid.
Peter Paul Rubens, Dance of Mythological Figures and Villagers Oil on canvas, ca. 1635–38. Museo del Prado, Madrid.
An LP promoted as a Scottish dance party, featuring the Jim Campbell Band.
An LP promoted as a Scottish dance party, featuring the Jim Campbell Band.
Front cover of an LP featuring remixes of La Macarena by Los del Río.
Front cover of an LP featuring remixes of La Macarena by Los del Río.
Back cover with step-by-step Macarena dance instructions.
Back cover with step-by-step Macarena dance instructions.
A painting by Korneli Szlegel depicting a traditional Polonaise dance.
A painting by Korneli Szlegel depicting a traditional Polonaise dance.
“Die Polonäse” by Gottlieb Wendehals has been a carnival hit since my childhood.
“Die Polonäse” by Gottlieb Wendehals has been a carnival hit since my childhood.
Nicolas Poussin, The Dance to the Music of Time, c. 1640.
Nicolas Poussin, The Dance to the Music of Time, c. 1640.
Cypriot terracotta statuette of a ring dance, ca. 7th century BCE.
Cypriot terracotta statuette of a ring dance, ca. 6th century BCE.
The Grand Entry at the Omaha Powwow.
The Grand Entry at the 1983 Omaha Powwow.
Henri Matisse, La Danse (The Dance), 1910.
Henri Matisse, La Danse (The Dance), 1910.
The Gilles performing their circle dance at the Binche Mardi Gras.
The Gilles performing their circle dance at the Binche Mardi Gras.
Hans Thoma, Kinderreigen (Children’s Round Dance), 1872.
Hans Thoma, Kinderreigen (Children’s Round Dance), 1872.
The illustrated cover of Ring O' Roses, a collection of nursery rhymes by Leonard Leslie Brooke.
The illustrated cover of Ring O' Roses, a collection of nursery rhymes by Leonard Leslie Brooke.
The original Barmaley Fountain in Volgograd (then Stalingrad), photographed by Emmanuil Yevzerikhin after German bombing in August 1942.
The original Barmaley Fountain in Volgograd (then Stalingrad), photographed by Emmanuil Yevzerikhin after German bombing in August 1942.
Igor Stravinsky, The Rite of Spring, 1913 is a ballet of ritual dance, sacrifice, and collective frenzy.
Igor Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring (1913) is a ballet of ritual dance, sacrifice, and collective frenzy.
Illustration from Ludwig Bechstein’s Deutsches Märchenbuch, depicting the wolf and the seven goat kids.
Illustration from Ludwig Bechstein’s Deutsches Märchenbuch, depicting the wolf and the seven goat kids.
Building the figures for the model used in my painting Der Wolf und die sieben jungen Geisslein (The Wolf and the Seven Little Kids).
Building the figures for the model used in my painting Der Wolf und die sieben jungen Geisslein (The Wolf and the Seven Little Kids).
Assembling the model for the painting Der Wolf und die sieben jungen Geisslein.
Assembling the model for the painting Der Wolf und die sieben jungen Geisslein.
The framed painting in my studio.
The framed painting in my studio.
Der Wolf und die sieben jungen Geisslein [The Wolf and the Seven Little Kids], (241L), 2019,oil on canvas, 275 x 195 cm
Der Wolf und die sieben jungen Geisslein [The Wolf and the Seven Little Kids], (241L), 2019, oil on canvas, 275 x 195 cm

Sign up to receive a brief update every two weeks when a painting is added.